We’ll examine two common roof options in our metal roof vs. shingles cost guide below, comparing not only the initial price but also the ongoing maintenance and repair expenses and potential resale value.
Shingles vs. Metal Roof Important Differences
The most obvious distinction between metal and shingle roofing is price. Nonetheless, a few more significant distinctions between metal and shingle roofing could convince you that metal roofing is a wise investment. Let’s examine this:
Prices
The type of metal or shingle type you select will determine how much a metal roof costs compared to shingles. Although asphalt shingles are the least expensive option, they are also the least resilient. Steel, tin, aluminum, zinc, and copper are the materials available for metal roofing; copper and zinc are the most expensive of the lot.
The average cost of a metal roof is $13,200, while the lowest cost is $8,800 usually with a maximum expense of $68,000
The average cost of a pair of a shingle roof is $8,500, with low to high prices varying from $5,500 to $12,000.
Although they need to be repaired far more frequently, asphalt shingle roofs are far simpler and less expensive to fix. Metal roofs typically endure for years without any problems, but even minor storms and ordinary wear and tear can cause damage that needs to be fixed right once.
Durability
Shingle roofs are far less durable than metal roofs. You could expect anywhere from 40 to 100 years—or perhaps longer—depending on the kind of metal you select.
An asphalt shingle roof can last, at most, 15 to 30 years if properly maintained. Although some wood shingle roofs can endure up to 50 years, they also need a lot of upkeep. Although clay tile (shingle) roofs are among the priciest kinds of shingle roofs, they can endure up to 50 years.
Effectiveness
Because metal roofs better retain heat in the winter, they may theoretically lower your energy expenses. They can, according to some estimates, cut your energy expenses by as much as 40%. You may determine just how much a metal roof might increase the efficiency of your house with the aid of a home energy assessment.
Beauty
Here’s where both kinds of roofs shine: Metal and shingle roofs are available in an array of designs and hues. Ultimately, it boils down to personal preference. Whatever material you decide on, it’s likely to complement the design of your house.
Value at Resale
Compared to asphalt shingles, metal roofs are more valuable when sold. If you intend to list your house within the next five years, bear this in mind.
Cost Comparison between Metal and Shingle Roofs
Metal roofs depending on whether they are made from steel, stainless steel, tin, aluminum, copper, or zinc can run from $300 to $2,300 per square and last between forty to one hundred plus years.
Shingle roofs made from asphalt, composite wood or clay can cost between $90 to $1,000 per square and last between fifteen and one hundred years.
Roof Shapes
The cost of any form of roof, but especially metal roofs, might increase due to oddly shaped roofs that require more intricate cutting. Labor expenses for installing metal and shingle roofs are further increased by steeper slopes and difficult-to-access roofs.
Location Is Important.
Your location has a big influence on the cost of metal and shingle roofs. You should budget more money if you live in a high-cost area—such as an urban or coastal one—than if you do so in a rural or suburban one. Yet, your labor expenses could also be greater if you reside in a distant location far from the majority of roofing providers.
The Costs of Installing a Metal Roof vs. Professional Shingles
Prepare yourself for a significant investment regardless of the material you select. Despite the low cost of the material, replacing your roof might take up a significant amount of your home improvement budget.
Costs of Materials
Depending on the style, roofing shingles can cost anywhere from $1 to $10 per square foot. Clay shingles can cost up to $10 per square foot, while asphalt shingles typically cost between $1 and $2. Remember that shingles are often offered for sale in 100 square foot squares. You could require one extra square because you have to account for material waste.
The cost of metal roof materials can range from $1 to $25 per square foot, depending on the type. Copper is by far the most expensive material, while steel is the most reasonably priced. Tin and aluminum are in the center.
Benefits and Drawbacks of Metal Roofs
Although metal roofs offer many benefits, there are certain drawbacks to take into account.
Advantages
Durability: Metal roofs usually have a longer lifespan than any other kind of roof. The average lifespan of a metal roof is more than 50 years; copper and zinc roofs, in particular, can endure more than a century. The drawback? On average, copper roofs cost more than $50,000.
Low maintenance: Metal roofs require little upkeep over their long lives, despite the fact that it can be expensive to maintain them.
Energy conservation: Metal roofs are thought to save up to 40% on energy costs, making them incredibly energy-efficient.
Drawbacks
Cost: In short, metal roofs are substantially more expensive than shingle roofs when comparing their costs.
Weight: Metal roofing weigh a lot. Prior to installation, you must determine the building’s load-bearing capacity.
Benefits and Drawbacks of Siding Roofs
Shingle roofs offer advantages and disadvantages of their own.
Advantages
Shingle roofs are the least expensive type of roof to install, especially asphalt roofs.
Simple to maintain: Although shingle roofs may not withstand the test of time, they are reasonably simple and inexpensive to maintain.
Drawbacks
Durability: While certain shingles are more resilient than others, they are not quite as strong as metal roofs. Over time, general wear and tear as well as severe storms may require you to replace sections of your shingle roof.
Energy: Metal roofs offer a higher level of energy efficiency than shingle roofs.
Resale value: When listing your house, shingle roofs don’t help you sell. Don’t expect a shingle roof to impress anyone, but a new roof of any kind can entice a buyer to make an offer (one less item for them to worry about fixing after they acquire ownership).
Choosing a Professional or Doing It Yourself: Installing Shingles or a Metal Roof
Installing a new roof is a risky and challenging task. For homeowners without prior roofing experience, the height and sun exposure present concerns. Inexperienced do-it-yourselfers may make minor mistakes that result in leaks and serious water damage. That’s why, whether your roof is made of metal or shingles, we always advise having a skilled roofing contractor install it.
Which Is Better for You, a Shingle Roof or a Metal Roof?
Many considerations must be made while deciding between a metal roof and a shingle roof, such as how much you can currently afford to pay, how long you plan to live in the home, how much you want to save on energy costs, etc. In the end, each form of roof has advantages and disadvantages and might be a wise investment for your house. Any kind of roof is ultimately preferable to none at all.
Residential & Commercial Roofing Services By Roof Pros Dallas, Inc.
If you are searching for commercial or residential roofing services in Addison, Arlington, Dallas, Fort Worth, Garland, Mesquite, or Plano, TX, Roof Pros Dallas, Inc. is here for you! You can trust the reliable repair service and high-quality materials we use for each and every project. From a small roofing repair to a complete replacement, the team at Roof Pros Dallas, Inc has you covered! Contact our experienced team today!
[/vc_column_text][/vc_column][/vc_row]
